SWINGTrader India

Looks like the gain/loss numbers in the websites are best case scenarios. I took couple of trades based on the recommendation. While recommendations seems to be good, it's extremely difficult to enter/exit at the price they suggest. For eg. Today morning I got an alert about removing GLAXO at a price of 1645. I got the notification at 9:50 am. But the price was never 1645₹ after the notification. So while the app shows a profit of 1%, I could exist only cost to cost.

Amazing experience with it. Since I have been using from last 1 month. Maximum calls are accurate. But one suggestion. If either whatsapp facility or text message facility of giving calls be provided. Coz its difficult to check updates via mail or application sometimes when v r busy. Text messages r easy to read rather than email.

Very bad service. I loss my 2000 rs on this app. Continue hitting SL. Very very very bad service.

First of all the past performance is a scam. They sent notification to enter the market at 100, by the time u get it will be 103 or more (they always sent it on a positive candle so always the price u enter will be higher) Same for SL they ask you to exit at 98, but by the time you exit it will be 95. According to their performance, it is a 2% loss. and for you the loss will be 4.8% more than double. The same apply for profit, they show 5% profit and u hardly get 2.5% because of the delay.

It's features not worth to invest in. Some of the practical factors like brokerage or response time not considered while displaying their profit and losses percentage. The actual success rate of winners is much lower than as shown. My subscription for it's yearly package is wasted. :(

Using this app for last 6 months. Earlier used to loose money. But I found out that the fault was mine. Actually they are providing a excellent system to earn decent amount of money. I feel bad for rating them low earlier. Now I have even subscribed to Market Smith India. To earn money one needs to introspect. Thanks for the excellent service. Regards

They are back on track with consistent performance, current months average return is 6%. Updated: Performance deteriorated past 1 month the average return is <-2% in the recent trades. recos from money control are much better than this. The price is almost negligible.

It's a good platform without fuss and complications. They may not be the first ones to catch the stock movement trends, however they get it earlier than most and give important & helpful information.

Useless recommendations The performance of the stock recommended is pathetic! The stocks will be removed from recommendations withinin 2-3 days

The entry alerts are always given after the entry price is crossed. When backtested with the past trades, only when you enter at the entry price, you have made money at the end of the year. So buying in the buy zone levels above entry price are not profit making. So not recommended. Didn't expect such a kind of products from a reputed company like William O Neil.

Biggest issue is late alerts. This must be corrected immediately to be successful. You say entry Price as X, but the time the alert is received price is much higher than X. Otherwise calls are good. One can end up with profits only when the late alerts issue can be resolved.

This app helped me in short term investments. The best part of this app is based on fundamentals and technical and also the stop loss percentage is very less when compared to other apps I have used. The app uses CANSLIM methodology which I have gone through in the book written by William O'Neil and I found it to be interesting concept.

Earlier had a problem with the bundled subscription not working, it somehow got fixed in 2-3 hours. The past trades list suggests a low success rate, but I'm going to try the current trades for few weeks and update this review.

So I took the trail package to see how effective these calls are but I found this to be useless incurring nothing but loss. All 5 stock recommendation that I received during the trail period hit stop loss incurring a good amount of loss as I invested in all 5 of them. So thier research is flawed and a waste of money. Plus no accountability if you incur losses.

Loved it. There is nothing else required from a swing trading perspective. Timely notifications with clear instructions, anyone with a year or so experience in trading can benefit greatly.

Good calls. Neatly organized telegram channel. One suggestion is sometimes the call comes to the telegram channel and on the app about 1-2 mins late which most times causes a difference of 1% or so. Guess it's due to admin tasks of forwarding, formatting etc. Please work on improving that.

Tried the Trial Version. Apprx 50- 60% calls were fine. The annual plan should be in the range of 5k since there is no dedicated RM, the suggestions are shared through automated mails/SMS options. Whatsapp option should be available.

Availed the free trial. Very poor calls at elevated prices. I picked up a few stocks based on their calls and all are down 3-9%. They should focus more on the analysis of a stock before recommending. I'd not even use their services even if it were free. Uninstalled!!

Amazing app and calls. I am using the trial and for sure pay for an year Success rate of calls is very high and they are vocal in their reviews while sending the sucess rate of the calls

I had good experience with fantastic technical calls. Out of 10 at least 5 to 6 will hit positively. Still more can improve to provide more informative on technicals as well as some fundamental info with analysis. I would request to have same on SELL calls where possible to make good returns over sell call trading. Swings trading is good for those Who wants to make returns on daily short term tradings.

Paid for the subscription, payment is successful but the subscription is not updated in the app. Tried to call and mail in all the support IDs and numbers provide. No response so far. Terrible customer service, not expected from a paid app.

So Many times i sent messages to Swintrader india telegram to add my Subscription to the tradesmith telegram channel,but no one is giving reply to the messages,what kind of paid subscription service provided by you..I have taken 2 years subscription during last diwali and still not added in the telegram..Poor after sale service.

very bad app. late notifications. plus the charts are incomplete and cannot be viewed in full screen.

I joined this app in the month of dec they promise me 30000 worth benifits and books but actually not provided I called support but no use

Either CAN SLIM is a failed investing technology or analysis at SwingTrader don't know how to apply it. Tried this for a month(booked more loss than profit) and have been analyzing their calls for couple of months, success rate was less than 45% even when nifty moved from 10800 to 12000!!

From one month all failed calls. Lost money. If market is volatile dont give any calls instead of giving failed calls and making us lose money. Nearly 15-20 failed calls. I think 80% of all calls failed in this month.

Hello This App Can be exceptionally great if you are able to provide watch list of stocks that may potentially added to SWTI CURRENT TRADES . If you can add this feature. We are extremely happy because we have clear idea from this stocks we may get signal . Please Provide watch list of stocks that may be added to CURRENT TRADES. If You Can Do this we can permanently get rid of delay in alerts.

Reputed company but always gives LOSS. Alerts come after the price goes far above to catch. I always think if I buy now or the price will come back. And finally loss. You calculate the price and loss based on your given price which is impossible for a customer to get. Please try to provide the alerts before 1 or half minute.

Please introduce Weekly, Fortnight and monthly subscriptions It will be easy to subscribe and customer base will increase if plan cost is low. Once, if the customers get confidence on your calls, there is no need for publicity.... Customers will publicize on behalf of you for free of cost.

Poor experience, i have tried around 30-40 trades. Booked stop loss in 20-25. Lost capital. My 2 year subscription has become a waste. Horrible app.